238 Pagosa St, Pagosa Springs, CO 81147
(970) 264-9348
Daily Menu
Holiday Menu OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK 7AM TO 6PM!
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About PBC
    • Sustainability
    • Media Mentions
    • Blog
  • Menu
    • Daily Menu
    • Monthly Specials
    • Bread Schedule
    • Holiday Specials
    • Catering
    • Sweets & Cakes
    • Sensitivity Menu
    • We Make U Bake
  • We are Foodies
    • Gingerbread House Contest
    • Sourdough Crock
    • Baking at Altitude
    • All Our Recipes
    • People We Love
  • Contact
    • Opportunities
  • Shop
  • Cart
    • Checkout
  • Log In

Handcrafted Baked Goods | Nourishing Simple Meals | Community Gathering Place

Coffee Shop Pagosa Springs CO Cafe

We are Foodies

December Newsletter

December 11, 2025 By Kathy Keyes

December Newsletter

 

  • Gingerbread House Contest and Holiday Open House
  • PCI Toy Drive 2025
  • Check out Holiday Products!
  • Christmas Week Orders
You’re invited to our

Holiday Open House

Sunday December 14, 1 pm to 3 pm

 

Join us to congratulate the Gingerbread House Contest Winners, and celebrate with free hot cocoa and cookies. If you haven’t voted for your favorite yet, click here. All proceeds support Rise Above Violence.

Judges will announce the winners at 2 pm. Many thanks to the talented baker/artists who’s time and talents make this community event fun and festive! Best of luck to you all!

Pagosa Community Initiative Toy Drive

Pagosa Baking Company is one of many sites in the county hosting a collection box for PCI Toy Drive. Bring in your new unwrapped toys to make a festive holiday for local kids. The toy drive ends Friday December 12. Thank you to our many generous customers who have been refilling the box regularly!

Pagosa Baking Co Holiday Products

Our staff has been busily hand decorating lovely Chocolate and Citrus Snowflakes, and dressing up adorable Ginger Folk. Traditional Stollen is on the shelves, wrapped for gift giving. Yolanda and team are stocking the take and bake freezer with seasonal favorites, like Tamales, Chicken Pot Pies, Cookie Dough and Green Chile Chicken Stew. Check out our Christmas menu here, and place your order by calling 970-264-9348.

Celebrate with Regional Flours, Grains & Beans

 

Pagosa Baking Company is a long time proponent of local and regionally produced foods. We are proud to carry Mountain Mama Milling Whole Wheat and Whole Rye Flours, which you’ll find in all our whole grain breads, scones and pie dough. We’ve stocked a variety of beans and grains grown regionally and packaged by Bow & Arrow, White Mountain Farm and Pueblo Seed Company Support our local grain economy by gracing your holiday table with these wonderful products. And what better way to share the gifts of the season with the bakers and cooks amongst your friends and family.

Filed Under: News

Construction Parking

July 10, 2025 By Kathy Keyes

Park in the Alley House lot east of Pagosa Baking Company.

Please note the small print:

Pagosa Baking Company 6 am to 3 pm

 

 

 

 

From the east, take 1st Street north and make a left onto Lewis Street.  Go one block and make a left onto 2nd Street.  You’ll see the alley entrance as in the photo.  Turn right into the alley, look for the sign above marking the entrance into the lot.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From Lewis Street west of the bakery, make a right onto 3rd Street and a left into the alley.  You’ll pass the rear of the bakery before seeing the sign marking the entrance to the parking lot.

 

 

 

 

 

Please park along the fence facing the bakery. Look for the Pagosa Baking Company banner on the fence:

There is a gate facing the highway which you will use to walk to the bakery:

Welcome!  We’re so glad you made the effort to visit us!

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: News

Chamber Business Spotlight

June 7, 2024 By Kathy Keyes

We’re so grateful to be featured in the Pagosa Springs Chamber of Commerce Business Spotlight!  Take a look…

 

Filed Under: News

Earth Day 2018

April 20, 2018 By Kathy Keyes

Earth Day 2018

Sustainability, everyday.

Pagosa Baking Company is committed to sustainability.  We use Colorado grown and milled flours; we choose compostable take out cups, cutlery and packaging; our building is geothermally heated; we recycle and compost.  Check out our Sustainability page.
Come on in for the fun goodies we’re making for Earth Day – Earthworm Cupcakes, and Shortbread cookies made in shapes to celebrate spring.  Check out the recipe.

In the Community

 Kathy and Kirsten have long contributed to sustainability in our community. Kirsten is running for our local electric coop board, LPEA, and has been involved in local geothermal development projects. Kathy is a founding board member and former president of the Geothermal Greenhouse Partnership.

Filed Under: News

Father’s Day 2017

June 6, 2017 By Kathy Keyes

Father’s Day 2017

Larry Keyes at a Paris Bakery, 1948

Peggy, Kathy & Larry Keyes at Pagosa Baking Company, 2006

Croissants and Love

While my dad was not the daily cook in the family, occasionally he would take on a big project, like fried wontons during a snow storm, or more often, a huge pot of spaghetti sauce.  The wontons covered both the dining room and kitchen tables, and induced a family sized ( I think there were only 3 of us kids then) food coma.  I have a very distinct memory of falling in love with butter when in an Adirondack cabin on vacation, he produced a big pot of elbow macaroni with butter and salt.  It was a revelation, as margarine was the spread used at home.  Dad’s experience of living in Paris as a teen inspired a love of croissants, and his love inspired me to make them.  When I was 11, I pulled out my mom’s Fannie Farmer cookbook, and made my first attempt.  It was an all day effort.  They turned out as one might expect – small, greasy, compact – but Dad praised them, and ate them.  I then moved on to cheese cake, another of his favorites, that required much less time and labor, and much better results.  The whole family ate that.

I’ve had much better success with croissants as an adult.  They sell out every day here at Pagosa Baking Company.  During a 2006 visit from my parents, I roped my mom and dad into helping out with a batch.  It was an act of memory, acknowledgement, connection, gratitude.  My dad didn’t support my early yearnings for a career in food, but he sure supported my love of creation and development of skills.  I still have and use the rolling pin he gave me.  His gift of the Reader’s Digest Creative Cooking cookbook – it’s contributors and editors are a list of who’s who food writers of the 50’s, 60’s and 70’s – stimulated my curiosity about world cuisines and seasonality.  I tribute my knife honing skills to Dad.  We butted heads about what I would study in college.  I wanted to go to Johnson and Whales, a cooking school in Providence RI.  Becoming a dietitian was Dad’s idea.  I got my degree in nutrition and food science, and after a decade working in clinical nutrition, I got my food career.  My food science background has been an invaluable resource.  Thanks, Dad.

Filed Under: News

Pagosa Baking Company’s Mascot – the Bear

March 31, 2017 By Kathy Keyes

Our Mascot, the Bear

or how two city chicks learned the woods may not be the best place to start a bakery…

Pagosa Baking Company began with a 30 qt Hobart mixer on the front porch, and more passion and enthusiasm than sense.  The renovation of our garage into a commercial baking kitchen 12 miles south of Pagosa Springs happened in December 2000.

We sold bread to our neighbors, from the back of the car, and from a couple of very hospitable local businesses (Handcrafted Interiors, Wolftracks Books & Coffee) .   It smelled pretty good in the neighborhood, and the bears noticed.  Kirsten came home one night to find the Shop Vac and a large sack of wheat bran sitting in the middle of the driveway.  The Shop Vac suffered some puncture wounds, and it was clear the bear did not find the wheat bran very tasty.  A few weeks later while we were out of town, our young neighbor and pet sitter Corbin arrived to find the sliding door wide open,  and 50# of sugar poured out of the bin onto the floor.  He scooped the sugar back into the bin and locked the sliding door.  We realized once we were returned that a case of walnuts, a case of raisins and a large box of shortbread cookies had disappeared as well.  Not satisfied, a few nights later the bear attempted another break in.  We found the screen door ripped out, bear claw punctures lining the door trim, and enormous muddy paw prints covering each window.  Not a happy guy…  Locked doors and windows became the rule.  Months later walking along the ditch, we found empty case boxes of walnuts and raisins.  I guess it was our contribution to his hibernation calorie stash that year.

Once we opened our retail location, shortbread bear cookies dipped in chocolate became the symbol of our bakery’s beginning in the kitchen in the woods, our mascot.  Join us on Sunday April 2, 2017, Pagosa Baking Company’s Local Appreciation Day, for a shortbread bear cookie on us, and share in our tradition.  Thanks for your support!

 

Kathy & Kirsten

 

Filed Under: News

Local Appreciation Day

March 27, 2017 By Kathy Keyes

PBC’s Local Appreciation Day

Celebrate with 25% Discount

We love our local customers!  We feel so fortunate to share a daily latte, create another birthday or anniversary cake, and feel the love of seeing our regulars, well, regularly!   We’ll celebrate with Local Appreciation Day on Sunday April 2, please join us!
When we opened Pagosa Baking Company in 2001, Kathy spent the wee hours baking in the commercial kitchen we’d created in our garage 12 miles south of town, and Kirsten hauled all the goodies up to our retail location at 238 Pagosa Street, made coffee, and sold the baked goods. It was our locals who gave us much needed encouragement,  and sales, of course!  They invited us into their lives with daily companionship, ordering goodies to mark family celebrations, and allowing us to share our passion for locally sourced quality foods.  Their feedback helped shape our product line and determine direction for growth.  On our first anniversary, our sole employee, Pam Spitler, asked what it was like to reach that benchmark.  My reply – I felt I was the captain of a ship, at the helm certainly,  but shaped by the waves, wind, crew.  Learning  how to navigate with flexibility may have been the first lesson our customers guided us to learn.  That quality of relationship has continued to this day.  We are grateful, and proud of the the role Pagosa Baking Company plays in our community.

Join us on Sunday April 2 so we can thank you with 25% off all PBC made baked goods and pastries.  Choose from breakfast pastries, pies and sweets in the pastry cases, and our Take ‘N Bake pies and cookie dough in the retail freezer. What a deal – take home a Chicken Pot Pie,or call us to bake it for you.  970-264-9348.

Thank you,

Kathy & Kirsten

Filed Under: News

Our First Blog Post

February 22, 2017 By Kathy Keyes

Welcome to our new website!  We’ve updated our look and  made it easier to find our monthly calendar menus.  I love the design by Ramblin Jackson, and Jacque Aragon’s photography of our food and space.  Our tag line – “Handcrafted Baked Goods, Nourishing Simple Meals, Community Gathering Place, Locally Sourced Organic Ingredients, Celebratory Fare” – is getting more prominence to highlight the connections we’ve spent the past 15 years creating.  Our mission is about relationship – amongst our staff, with our customers, vendors, the organizations we sponsor, the community at large.  Food and customer service are our medium, platforms to express our creativity, and the vehicles to uphold our end of the relationships.  What a privilege!  Every day I get to move the business forward with committed staff, engage with them in passionate creation,  share the fruits of our creations with our wonderful customers, participate in growing community in spectacular Pagosa Springs.  I am grateful to you for your support, which keeps this endeavor going.  I invite you to peruse the pages here as we continue to refine the site, follow blog posts, use our recipes, make suggestions for future content.

Carrot Cake Muffins

Created by Kathy Keyes on February 22, 2017

Pagosa Baking Company Carrot Cake Muffins First recipe, our Carrot Cake Muffins. One of the most popular items in the pastry case, this same recipe is also one of our most requested wedding cakes. In this basic spice cake recipe, shredded carrots lend moisture and tenderness as in zucchini bread or apple sauce cake. We...

  • Category: Please click on the Recipe title to see the entire recipe details.

Ingredients

  • 10 ounces all purpose flour
  • 3/4 teaspoon baking powder
  • 3/4 teaspoon baking soda
  • 2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 10 fluid ounces canola oil
  • 11 1/2 ounces granulated sugar
  • 5 eggs
  • 11 ounces shredded fresh carrots
  • 3 1/2 ounces chopped walnuts
  • 4 1/2 ounces raisins

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 325 degrees. Coat a large 12 count muffin plaque with pan spray. Or, coat a 9" cake pan with pan spray, place a round of parchment paper in the bottom of the pan. Combine the flour, cinnamon, baking soda and powder, and salt in a medium bowl with a wisk. In a mixing bowl, blend the oil, sugar, and eggs well. Add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients. Mix to thoroughly combine the dry ingredients into the wet, but be sure to not over mix. Add the shredded carrots, raisins and walnuts, being sure to not over mix. Pour the batter into the prepared pan/s (5 oz batter per muffin cup). Bake at 325 degrees. The muffins will take 30 to 35 minutes. The cake will take 45 to 55 minutes. Insert a small knife or toothpick into the center of a muffin or the cake - you will see moist crumbs, not sticky batter, when the muffins or cake is done. Cool for 15 minutes, them remove the muffins or cake from the pan/s. Completely cool before icing or storing. Carrot cake is delicious on it's own, with a drizzle of honey, some butter, whipped cream or cream cheese icing. You could also make this in a pretty fluted pan to serve like a simple pound cake.
  • Print

Pagosa Baking Company Carrot Cake Muffins

Filed Under: News, Recipes

Browse Our New Website!

June 20, 2016 By Kirsten

We’re thrilled to launch our new website this month, complete with new images of our location and delicious food. Browse the site and let us know what you think!

pagosa-baking-company_7811

Filed Under: News

New website in works

February 16, 2015 By Anthony Crowley

We’ll be lost in the clouds briefly while we update our website,

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

September 2022 Closed Monday through Thursday

9/12 through 9/15 and 9/19 through 22

Regular hours:

Open 6 days a week!

Wednesday through Monday 7 am to 2 pm

Closed Tuesdays

Call (970) 264-9348 to order

  • TripAdvisor

 

  • TripAdvisor

Recent Posts

  • December Newsletter
  • Construction Parking
  • Chamber Business Spotlight

Recent Recipes

  • Pumpkin Muffins, Gluten Free
  • Strawberry or Raspberry Rhubarb Pie Filling
  • PBC Green Chile Chicken Stew
  • Carrot Cake Muffins
  • Pagosa Baking Company Shortbread

Footer

About Us:

Located at 238 Pagosa St, Pagosa Springs, CO 81147, Pagosa Baking Company is dedicated to creating and sharing handcrafted baked goods, nourishing meals and celebratory fare utilizing locally sourced organic ingredients, and so much more! Read on ...

Newsletter Signup

connect with us:

COPYRIGHT © 2006–2026 PAGOSA BAKING COMPANY. All Rights Reserved.

  • 0